By DANIEL STONE
As a health care provider, I take into account Secretary Xavier Becerra and his Division of Well being and Human Companies (HHS) to be allies of practitioners like me. The behemoth federal company administers Medicare and Medicaid, the Meals and Drug Administration, and a military of public well being employees. The Surgeon Basic, symbolic chief of the nation’s healthcare suppliers, experiences to HHS. For many years, the Division has supported medical science in safeguarding the general public’s well being. Now that sacred belief faces the specter of Donald Trump’s nomination of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to run HHS.
RFK’s first drawback is a surprising lack of {qualifications}. After a laudable overcome drug habit, he used his authorized background to work on environmental safety. Kennedy by no means held a federal authorities place nor administered any public company. He now seems poised for on-the-job coaching at an company with 80,000 workers and a $1.7 Trillion funds. In distinction, Becerra served for years in Congress and on its Well being Sub-Committee. He additionally served as State Lawyer Basic, managing 4,800 workers. The qualification challenge just isn’t political. Throughout Trump’s first time period, his final HHS secretary, Alex Azar, had served as HHS basic counsel and president of pharmaceutical big Eli Lilly. RFK has nothing remotely resembling his would-be predecessors’ {qualifications}.
Sadly, RFK’s shortcomings go effectively past mere lack of qualification. His distortions and public denials of established medical science infuriate practitioners like me. He casts baseless doubt on the well-established advantages of vaccines and on the polio vaccine in particular. Regardless of the seven a long time since polio vaccine’s introduction, docs nonetheless see sufferers who have been contaminated earlier than it was accessible. My affected person Donna, born in 1955, counts herself amongst this group. She wears leg braces and sometimes struggles with each day actions. For me, she symbolizes those that by chance of start or happenstance missed the profound advantages of vaccines that RFK now disparages.
RFK additionally opposes fluoridation of water. One other affected person, Judith, age 80, scoffs at such skepticism. She grew up in Niagara Falls, NY, earlier than fluoridation and its dental safety. She remembers her childhood dentist discovering 13 cavities and the trauma and ache of extended dental work at an early age.
Major care docs like me spend our skilled lives working to stop life limiting and life-threatening circumstances like these affecting Donna and Judith. We wrestle with the challenges of insurance coverage denials, clunky digital information, healthcare paperwork and ballooning affected person masses. We don’t want an HHS administrator opposing our efforts to offer normal preventive care. And if RFK’s judgment on vaccines is so poor, who can belief him on different essential healthcare points like pandemic administration or drug authorizations?
How ought to physicians reply? I not too long ago exchanged messages with a politically numerous group of native medical leaders. All of them opposed RFK however disagreed on techniques. Some mentioned that the American Medical Affiliation management believes RFK to be headed for affirmation. They concern that failed opposition would possibly jeopardize RFK’s assist on Medicaid and Medicare reimbursements.
The native docs’ reasoning displays the identical transactional “what’s in it for me” method that led to RFK’s nomination. RFK mortgaged a share of the Kennedy legacy to assist Trump win the Presidency. Now Trump is returning the favor with a cupboard place regardless of RFK’s lack of {qualifications} and practitioners’ opposition. Ought to organized drugs actually undertake the identical “what’s in it for us” method?
I informed my colleagues that I can settle for being on the dropping facet. Regardless of my efforts, my sufferers generally get sick and even die. However I don’t stop on them or ask, “what’s in it for me?” So I can’t shrug my shoulders as these representing America’s docs swallow RFK’s nomination like a dose of castor oil. The senators voting on RFK have their very own docs and medical societies of their house states. These docs should clarify to their senators why RFK is unacceptable to these on healthcare’s entrance strains.
I can’t shrug my shoulders as these representing America’s docs swallow RFK’s nomination like a dose of castor oil. I’ve belonged to the California Medical Affiliation for greater than 20 years and to the American School of Physicians, the nation’s largest medical commerce affiliation, for over 30. Though happy with these associations, I’ll resign from each in the event that they fail to challenge sturdy, evidence-based statements explaining why the RFK nomination is unacceptable. I hope my colleagues do likewise.
As physicians, we take an oath to do no hurt. Generally doing nothing causes hurt. It’s time for organized drugs to do the fitting factor and battle the RFK nomination.
Daniel Stone is a practising internist and geriatrician with Cedars Sinai Medical Group. This piece was initially published in the Jewish Journal
